Tag Archives: disillusionment

Bradshaw: Why I write about students — not the system

Most education coverage in America focuses on teachers, professors, or the institutions themselves. The system, not the student, dominates the headlines. We hear endlessly about teachers’ unions, tenure reform, DEI mandates, grade inflation, or the latest university scandal. Yet behind every statistic and policy paper stands a living, thinking student — the one figure almost invisible in our national conversation about learning.

That absence is what drives my column.

For decades, I’ve written about the real people who sit in classrooms, fill out applications, and fight to make sense of the world that older generations built for them. Students—whether they’re high-school juniors in Crown Point or international scholars from Istanbul—are the pulse of education. They embody its hopes, its fears, and increasingly, its disillusionment.

### The Missing Voice

Media coverage of education often treats students as objects of policy rather than subjects of experience. When standardized testing is debated, we hear from testing companies and university admissions officers, but rarely from the students who must live with the results.

When artificial intelligence enters the classroom, the op-eds feature professors warning about plagiarism, not the young people learning to wield these new tools responsibly and creatively.

The result is a portrait of education without its most essential voice. I write to correct that imbalance.

Students are not passive recipients of instruction; they are the experimenters, the skeptics, the restless minds who constantly test the assumptions of their elders. They are the ones who reveal where the system fails and where it still inspires.

Every column I write tries to give them back their agency.

### The View from the Desk, Not the Podium

My background shapes that focus. Having taught and advised hundreds of students over the years, I’ve learned that their stories—not institutional press releases—reveal the true state of American education.

A high-school senior wrestling with her essay for Stanford teaches us more about resilience and purpose than any government report on “student outcomes.” A first-generation college applicant struggling to balance ambition with family expectations exposes the moral tension that data can’t measure.

Too many journalists and educators write from the podium, looking down. I prefer to sit at the desk, looking across.

The difference in perspective changes everything: humility replaces jargon, empathy replaces policy, and the question becomes not “What should we teach?” but “What do they need to learn to thrive?”

### The AI Generation

Nowhere is this shift more urgent than in the age of artificial intelligence.

While faculty panels debate whether AI threatens “academic integrity,” students have already moved on—they’re using it to learn, to think, and sometimes to cheat, yes, but mostly to explore. They are the first generation whose intellectual tools are truly post-human, and they are figuring out the moral terrain as they go.

The media too often portrays them as reckless experimenters; I see them as pioneers. Their curiosity, not our fear, will determine the boundaries of this new world.

That’s why I cover AI not as an enemy of education but as a mirror of it. How students use or misuse it will tell us what kind of citizens they are becoming.

### Why It Matters

Writing about students is not a sentimental choice; it’s an intellectual one. They are the best measure of a culture’s health. How a society treats its learners says more about its future than how it pays its teachers.

A good student is not just a consumer of education but a participant in civilization’s ongoing argument with itself. When that argument becomes one-sided—when we stop listening to the young—we lose our capacity to renew ourselves.

That’s why I continue to focus on them, even as the headlines drift toward politics and policy.

Teachers deserve their due; teachers and professors deserve respect; but students deserve a voice. They are the beginning, not the end, of every educational story worth telling.

### Closing the Loop

So when I invite feedback from readers and editors, it isn’t just to polish a column—it’s to sharpen its purpose.

Every improvement in my writing is ultimately a service to the students whose experiences animate it. Their stories deserve clarity.

If journalism is, as someone once said, “the first draft of history,” then student journalism—the kind I strive to practice—is the first draft of the future.
https://www.chicagotribune.com/2025/10/30/bradshaw-why-i-write-about-students-not-the-system/